How to adjust the (aftermarket) Suspension.

This section is a culmination of what the site's users feel are common questions, or topics that seem to repeat a lot. Users are encouraged tp post to this section, but PLEASE DO NOT PUT GENERAL BANTER IN HERE, just factual/informational stuff. Please try and keep this section structured and neat!

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
Lost Rider
Basic User
Posts: 1629
Joined: Sat May 20, 2006 1:31 am
Donating Member #: 514
Location: Ventura County, California
Contact:

How to adjust the (aftermarket) Suspension.

Post by Lost Rider »

This was posted by Don in one of my threads, and I feel that it deserves its own thread - for people who might not want to hear my ramblings in my threads....

Thanks again to Don for this great write up! This should be a sticky. =D>


MOD EDIT - And I moved a copy of it here for posterity. Thanks to Joe and Don for the effort.





Sag is pretty easy...


Preload is set with everything on the bike that you'd normally ride with. If you ride with saddlebags of rocks - you want the saddlebags of rocks on the bike. You need to take the measurements with the bike AS YOU NORMALLY RIDE IT..

Static sag - you measure the height difference between the suspension fully extended, and the suspension with just the weight of the bike (and whatever you normally carry on it). On the R12R - I found it easy to measure using a tape measure hooked in the hole in the rear axle to one of the bag mounts. It's best if you're measuring at a right angle to the surface of the earth.. horizontally (up-down). The usual technique is to measure the bike on the centerstand and make sure your rear wheel is off the ground (no problem on mine..) then bounce the bike off the centerstand, and having someone help you hold it upright (without putting any downward force on the bike) and measure the same spots. Subtract the bigger from the smaller and that's static sag. On my Hyperpro's they call for 10mm +/- 5mm static sag on a factory spec sheet that came with the shocks.

There are some fancy techniques for getting rid of stiction effects on the measurement if you want to get fussy with it.. this is done on the "on the wheels" measurement (it doesn't make any difference on the unloaded measurement).. that's to first take a measurement after pushing down on the rear and letting it rise on itself. Then you take a second measurement after lifting the rear and letting it settle by itself. You take the average of the 2 numbers (A&B)/2=C as your weighted distance. I wouldn't bother on the roadster - I tried this and there was no measureable difference (sign of a good low-stiction suspension!)

Static sag is a good starting point IF the manufacturer gives you the expected static sag.

On my shocks, they came set from the factory with too much static sag (too little "preload") - the bike sat lower than it should which caused it bottom and hit the rubber bumper on the shaft too often, kicking my butt out of my seat. Increasing the preload in the rear decreased the sag - and it no longer felt harsh. This seems counterintuitive, but sometimes tightening up the spring will make it feel softer. Go figure.. I also put on a few pounds over the past few weeks, and my butt was getting kicked again.. finally dawned on me last night to up the preload a few clicks, and my ride to work was kick-free :-)

The more important measurement is dynamic sag - ie - the compression with your butt in the seat.

With a linear (not progressively wound) spring - the rule of thumb is 1/3rd the total suspension travel = correct dynamic sag. It's a rule of thumb making for a good starting point.. some adjustment up/down is probably going to be necessary, but it will get you very close to where it should be.

NOTE - I said "linear" spring. I got fooled on the Hyperpro's which come with progessive wound springs. A progressive wound spring starts out soft and as it gets compressed gets stiffer. A linear spring, provides linear force throughout it's length (until the coils start touching, aka "coil-bound"). It turns out I needed more dynamic preload (less sag) with the progressively wound spring due to the non-linear characteristics.. I found about 1/4 travel dynamic preload to be workable for the progessively wound springs.. What's interesting - Hyperpro gives no dimension or guide to dynamic, probably because of the progessive manner of the springs. But - I've digressed..

OK - measuring your dynamic sag - use the first measurement from your static sag - suspension fully extended, then plop your butt on the bike, and just balancing it on your tippie-toes with absolutely as little force on your toes as possible - make the loaded measurement. Do the math (A-B)=C and C is your dynamic sag. BMW claims 140mm travel on the stock rear suspension (I calculated about 135mm - but they're close..) That is IF the rubber bumper on the shock were fully compressed and the shock went metal to metal. Since that's not going to happen, in reality - the rear has about 120mm of useable travel with the stock suspension. You want the dynamic sag to be 1/3rd that number, or ~40mm (+/-5mm)

===================================================================================

That's the rear - the front is even easier to measure.. you just need a tie-wrap.

Put a small tie-wrap snuggly (not tight) around the left fork leg above the slider. Push it down onto the top of the slider-seal so it's just touching. Take the bike gently off the centerstand so it doesn't bounce. The tie-wrap will move up as the suspension compresses. Gently put it back on the centerstand and make sure the front wheel is "unloaded" (press down rear wheel until front is off the ground.)

Measure between the bottom of the tie-wrap and the top of the slider seal. That's your static sag.

To measure the dynamic sag, gently take it off the centerstand, and gently put your butt on the seat (no bouncing) - again tippie-toe again. Gently get off and put it on the centerstand. Repeat the measurement - that's your dynamic (loaded) sag. Usually the two dimensions aren't hugely different.

To find the total travel of the front suspension - just leave the tie wrap on and go for a vigorous ride on a bumpy road. Put bike on centerstand and repeat the measurement between bottom of tie-wrap and top of fork slider.

I didn't do this on the stock suspension when I had it on - but I asked Fred H to on his.. he measured about 104mm (from memory).. with my lowered suspension, I get a total travel measurement of about 85mm (the bike was lowered 20mm.. so it makes sense.) You want your dynamic (loaded) sag to be ~ 1/3rd the total travel - or around 35mm +/-5mm for stock suspension. (1/4 travel for progressive wound springs..)

That's where you start. If the boss isn't watching later I'll try writing up setting the damping.. which is more of a challenge to describe. SAG is easy..

_________________
Don Eilenberger - NJ Shore
2007 R1200R - I love this bike!


The ride in this morning was a "duh" moment. The "duh" being I should have realized I needed more preload on the rear shock.. since my legs had gotten longer again (more easily reaching the ground = suspension is lower = more dynamic sag.) The progressive wound springs are tricky to work with since the spring rate changes the more the spring is compressed. Normal springs (linear) have a constant rate...

The only bumps that I really "felt" a kick on this AM are the usual NJ expansion-joint-paved-over ones.. think of a bump about 3-4" high, about 5-6" of travel over it. These are caused by NJ liking to pave over the old concrete highways of the 1920's with asphalt, and the expansion joints between concrete slabs pull in the asphalt when it's cold out and the concrete shrinks, and then push it up into a speed-bump when the concrete is hot and expands.

The flow is only in one direction it seems - the lumps are pretty much permanant. Every 15-20 years the state first sends around a truck to grind them down.. which is good for a year, then potholes start forming so the patch crew shows up and makes a lump again. Then the state sends around the centerline painting crew, which means a week later the road is repaved (have to keep the paving companies at work!) and it's smooth for about a year. Then the speed-bumps start reforming. I'm old enough to have observed the cycle several times on our local highways..

Anyway - as counterintuitive as it might seem - compressing the spring more (dynamic sag decrease) made it more comfortable.. the shock was no longer bottoming on the rubber full-compression bumper. I should probably write that down on the bike somewhere.

When I got to work, I added 3 clicks of rebound damping.. I'll try explaining that soon..




OK.. have a few minutes.. I'll try first describing what the damping adjustments are on shocks, and what each one is designed to do:

===================================================================================

Compression damping: Pretty much self-explanatory.. it provides control of the resistance the shock has to compressing. While the spring provides most of the force resistance, the damping controls the speed that the compression can happen at. It normally does this by forcing oil through a controlled size passage. The laws of fluid movement end up working here.. to move X fluid in T-time through a fixed size hole requires Y force. To move X*2 (twice the fluid) in T-Time through the same hole will require Y*4 in force.

Simply said: The force required goes up as the square of the SPEED of the movement.

Some shocks have high and low speed compression damping adjustments. (Wilbers, Hyperpro, YSS) These terms mean are a bit confusing - they don't refer to the speed of the bike, they refer to the speed of the movement of the shock, which can be entirely different.

The "high" speed compression damping controls the movement/response of the shock to FAST compression of the shock. An example of a fast-speed compression would be the expansion joints I go over on my way to work. Short fast movement is controlled by the "high-speed" compression damping.

The "low" speed compression damping controls the movement/response of the shock to SLOW compression of the shock. An example of low-speed compression would be the suspension compressing as you enter a corner and weight is put on the suspension due to the force of the cornering. Low speed compression damping prevents the compression from happening too fast.

Other shocks - Ohlins simply have a single compression circuit that controls both high-low speed. While this might seem a compromise - IMHO it's not an awful compromise. While I can feel the difference tweaking the high/low speed settings on Wilbers and Hyperpro shocks, I've also been able to get excellent control and feel on Ohlins shocks with the single adjustment. Even on the shocks with both adjustments - there is an interaction between the high/low speed damping, and Hyperpro recommends that they never be more than a few clicks different in adjustment.

===================================================================================

Rebound damping controls the speed the shock extends from a compressed state. If you think of a shock with no rebound damping - going into a corner - the shock would compress and then immediately try to fully extend itself - making for unsettled suspension and a pogo-stick sort of feeling. This is the most common damping adjustment - the BMW stock rear shock has only rebound damping adjustment, for a good reason.. too much can be as bad as too little.

The reason too-much rebound can be bad - is called "stacking up" - where repeated bumps (think washboard surface) compresses the shock, and the excessive rebound damping keeps it from extending.. eventually the shock will be fully compressed and bottoming out. It also can effect how a shock "follows" a single bump (like our usual expansion joint) - if the shock doesn't allow the suspension to unload at the speed the wheel travels over the bump (and down the back side of it) - the rider will feel a thump/kick as the wheel drops off the bump, rather than following the change in profile.

===================================================================================




Suspension setup - final installment (I think..)

===========================================================================

Since I covered all the terms, and how to setup your spring preload, I'll try to briefly cover setting the damping on shocks that allow this..

First - you need an afternoon, good weather, plenty of time. You need to check and adjust your tire pressure. Carry the load on the bike you normally carry. And you need a course. I have a loop that I use that has the following features:

Long straight section
Washboard section
Pavement cuts - poorly filled
Light traffic
Safe place to pull over to make adjustments

The loop is about 5 miles in length, and takes me about 8 minutes to do. It has a decent spot to pull off to the side where I can make adjustments without worrying about a car running into me, and it has little traffic usually.

I first start out making 2 loops of my route - just to get the feel of how the suspension now feels and determine what I think could be improved. I'm looking for:

High speed stability in the straight section - I can hit about 70 on the straight section, not terribly fast, but fast enough to feel if the bike feels "stable" and "planted" at speed
Comfortable ride - the washboard section and the pavement cut (badly filled - nice sharp edges about 2' apart) will tell me if the suspension is compliant. The washboard will tell me if the rebound damping is too high and "packing down", the sharp edges will tell me if the compression damping (especially on shocks with two compression adjustments - the high-speed adjustment) is correct.
The twisties section tells me if the control feels good - and control is really changed with rebound damping on twisties. Too much rebound and the bike feels wooden and starts to compress and run wide (rake increases), too little and the bike will have an unsettled feeling - not-planted feeling. Too much low-speed compression damping will result in the suspension jacking up, and the bike turning in quicker - again - not-planted feeling.

What do I do to make the adjustments?

IMPORTANT - only adjust one thing at a time. ONE THING. Making more than one adjustment will lead to rampant confusion, I know, I've done it.

First a note on how to make any adjustment:

Start out with a large adjustment so you can FEEL the effect the adjustment has. On compression adjustments, I usually turn the adjuster 3 or 4 clicks higher, which should make a very noticeable difference in feel. Once I make the adjustment, I circle the loop, as many times as needed to be sure I feel exactly what the adjustment did.

IF the adjustment made things feel better (in this case - high-speed compression might make the sharp edge of the pavement cutout feel less sharp) - then I continue making adjustments on that adjuster until things feel worse - and I make smaller (1-2 clicks) adjustments. Once the adjustment starts feeling worse - reverse direction and work back toward where it felt better. Continue in that direction until it feels worse - then reverse again and narrow it down to the single click position that feels "best"..

If your initial big adjustment immediately made it feel worse - go back to where you started - and go for a big adjustment in the other direction. Then work your way in to where it feels best.

Doing ONE adjustment at a time will teach you what adjustments change what feeling in the bike..

In general:

High speed compression - changes sharp shock response, the badly patched pavement-cut with a sharp edge. Too much will shock you, too little feels unstable.

Low speed compression - does the bike feel "planted" - especially in curves? If not - increase low speed compression until it does. Too much low speed compression can make the bike start to hike-up, with the rear suspension jacking upward over undulating pavement, or a series of curves. In that case the bike will start to turn sharper into turns as the rake on the front end is decreased by the rising rear suspension.

Rebound - the washboard section is usually good to adjust this - if the bike seems to "pack down" - compress the rear suspension over the washboard, it will become harsher as you travel through the washboard, it will also become slower to respond on curves (tend to run wide) since the rake is increasing with the lowered rear suspension. Rebound also can cause sharp impacts to feel harsher if the wheel isn't recovering (rebounding) fast enough due to too much rebound. Too little rebound can give a pogo sort of feeling, especially in the twisties section as the suspension loads and unloads.

That's the basics - and using a course, giving yourself plenty of time will give you a chance to learn how the adjustments change the bike. The adjustments DO interact to some degree.. you may find adding more rebound might mean you also need a bit less compression damping..

It's sorta fun to do if you attack it as a puzzle, and do it very methodically. Make ONE adjustment at a time is the biggest rule! Doing otherwise will lead to brain-fog. BTDT.

_________________
Don Eilenberger - NJ Shore
2007 R1200R - I love this bike!
Get Lost!
User avatar
Lost Rider
Basic User
Posts: 1629
Joined: Sat May 20, 2006 1:31 am
Donating Member #: 514
Location: Ventura County, California
Contact:

Re: How to adjust the (aftermarket) Suspension.

Post by Lost Rider »

Don, any suggestions for shock changes when riding off road?

Say to give you a softer ride, but not bottoming out?
Get Lost!
deilenberger
Honorary Lifer
Posts: 4210
Joined: Thu May 03, 2007 9:21 pm
Donating Member #: 0
Location: New Jersey USA
Contact:

Re: How to adjust the (aftermarket) Suspension.

Post by deilenberger »

ChiTown wrote:Don, any suggestions for shock changes when riding off road?

Say to give you a softer ride, but not bottoming out?
Good question. Dunno - I used to ride dirty bikes for quite a few years, but the suspension I had was primative to say the least. Off road benefits from long travel, so anything you can do to achieve that should help. On a dirty bike - getting over logs (enduro type riding) is done by fully compressing the front suspension right before the log, then popping it up and using your weight to increase the momentum - holding it up until the front wheel goes over the top of the log. Probably increasing rake would be a good thing since it adds stability which can be tricky in soft stuff when the front wheel wants to stuff itself under the bike on turns.

Not sure, and don't want to get someone hurt, but I'd say the same ideas on tuning would work. Establish a route with terrain you expect to encounter, then make changes one at a time to see what helps or makes things worse. Repeat until you can't improve it any more.
Don Eilenberger - NJ Shore
2012 R1200R - I love this bike!
User avatar
Dan-A
Member
Posts: 422
Joined: Fri Aug 17, 2007 11:18 am
Donating Member #: 613
Location: Sacramento CA
Contact:

Re: How to adjust the (aftermarket) Suspension.

Post by Dan-A »

Great write up Don. I also saw your article in BMW MOA on farkelizing the R1200R Part II.

You da man!
Dan-A
BMW MOA # 137114
BLOG: http://danzgarage.net
Post Reply