Does Your Tank Suck?
Moderator: Moderators
Does Your Tank Suck?
When I pull in to gas up I have to gently pull open the filler cap against a vacuum in the tank (it gives a sucking "whooosh" when the seal breaks) Do..."they all do that"?
Rich
ADIOS!
ADIOS!
-
DJ Downunder
- Honorary Lifer
- Posts: 4776
- Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2005 3:26 pm
- Location: Melbourne
- jfslater98
- Quadruple Lifer
- Posts: 490
- Joined: Thu Sep 15, 2005 11:20 am
- Location: Northern NJ
-
Charles960
- Basic User
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Mon Jul 31, 2006 6:38 pm
- Location: Atlanta
pinched vent tube?
Wonder if they are clogged or pinched. I don't really know if that would even cause a vacuum.
Charles
Charles
I never had this problem, until last summer, when the BMW tech took the gas tank off my bike and I was told that the hoses were reversed and he put them back in the correct position. From that moment on, I always have problem opening the gas tank. Every time I need to gas up, it looks like that the ignition key will break, while I pull on it to open the tank. I think it has something to do with the canister.
TicTac50 wrote:I think it has something to do with the canister.
TicTac50,
If the charcoal cannister is clogged the gas tank cannot vent. This is (almost always) caused by repeteadly overfillng the tank, which is vented through the cannister. The result is a charcoal cannister clogged with fuel, and vacum build up in the tank . On my "K" bikes the common solution was to remove the cannister, put it in the trash and reconnect the vent tubes. Then rerout the vent tube to the spot on the bike where the other overflow tubes exit.
I will not get into into it here, but the vacum build up can cause a host of problems.
Hope this helps.
- CycleRob
- Honorary Lifer
- Posts: 2857
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2005 12:29 am
- Location: Enjoying retirement in Gainesville GA. USA
- Contact:
Like Arbee said, the vent line(s) are pinched off or swap connected. Get it looked at by the dealer and be firm about resolving it as it's an emission related malfunction that can damage the fueltank. Especially if the problem occurred AFTER the dealer said they were swap connected.
My fuelcap never has suction on it since July 2001.
Here's my copy-n-pasted solution from Aug 2006 on how to test and correct your vent hose connections:
To check if your 2002 model hoses are hooked up right you need to do a simple mouth-on-the-hose blow test. If you want an easy check without taking anything apart, put the bike on the centerstand for stability. Next, get a wet paper towel to clean off the 2 dirty drain hose ends hanging downward below the right footpeg. Do the larger diameter hose first, then the smaller hose last as it is the battery vent hose. Standing on the right side of the bike, open the fuel filler cap, put a paper towel or rag in the filler pocket to prevent water or dirt from entering the gastank opening during this invasive test. Next, put your finger over the little hole at the 9 O'Clock position (front is 12 O'Clock). Then kneel down and blow into the LARGER open ended hose. Avoid all contact with the smaller diameter hose's end as it goes to your battery and it may still have Sulfuric acid residues in it or oozing out it's tip, so be careful contacting the open end. As you blow into the only other larger sized hose, you should feel air coming out that 9 O'Clock hole up top where your finger is. If your drain hose has residual rainwater or fuel-up spilled fuel in it, that may also squirt out at your finger and hopefully be captured by the stuffed-in-the-opening papertowel.
If you don't feel any air coming out the 9 O'Clock position of the fuel filler hole even though you are able to puff air into it, remove the towel/rag, fully close the fuelcap and blow into the same hose again. You should now get the sensation of inflating a large balloon. After 2 or 3 quick "inflation" breaths, the air should then blow back out the hose end at your lips confirming that your hoses were mixed up!
If you have it all apart and can individually put lips on both of the plastic connector fittings attached to the fueltank vent hoses, you should be able to figure out that blowing air out the 9 O'Clock hole means it goes downward to the street drain. The other one, that tries to inflate the closed up fueltank, goes to the canister.
To avoid this mix-up again, you can either label the hoses with tape or WhiteOut . . . .
-or-
Leave one of the male connectors with the bike AND the other male connector with the tank hose providing foolproof gender mating.
My fuelcap never has suction on it since July 2001.
Here's my copy-n-pasted solution from Aug 2006 on how to test and correct your vent hose connections:
To check if your 2002 model hoses are hooked up right you need to do a simple mouth-on-the-hose blow test. If you want an easy check without taking anything apart, put the bike on the centerstand for stability. Next, get a wet paper towel to clean off the 2 dirty drain hose ends hanging downward below the right footpeg. Do the larger diameter hose first, then the smaller hose last as it is the battery vent hose. Standing on the right side of the bike, open the fuel filler cap, put a paper towel or rag in the filler pocket to prevent water or dirt from entering the gastank opening during this invasive test. Next, put your finger over the little hole at the 9 O'Clock position (front is 12 O'Clock). Then kneel down and blow into the LARGER open ended hose. Avoid all contact with the smaller diameter hose's end as it goes to your battery and it may still have Sulfuric acid residues in it or oozing out it's tip, so be careful contacting the open end. As you blow into the only other larger sized hose, you should feel air coming out that 9 O'Clock hole up top where your finger is. If your drain hose has residual rainwater or fuel-up spilled fuel in it, that may also squirt out at your finger and hopefully be captured by the stuffed-in-the-opening papertowel.
If you don't feel any air coming out the 9 O'Clock position of the fuel filler hole even though you are able to puff air into it, remove the towel/rag, fully close the fuelcap and blow into the same hose again. You should now get the sensation of inflating a large balloon. After 2 or 3 quick "inflation" breaths, the air should then blow back out the hose end at your lips confirming that your hoses were mixed up!
If you have it all apart and can individually put lips on both of the plastic connector fittings attached to the fueltank vent hoses, you should be able to figure out that blowing air out the 9 O'Clock hole means it goes downward to the street drain. The other one, that tries to inflate the closed up fueltank, goes to the canister.
To avoid this mix-up again, you can either label the hoses with tape or WhiteOut . . . .
-or-
Leave one of the male connectors with the bike AND the other male connector with the tank hose providing foolproof gender mating.
`09 F800ST
Member since Sept 10, 2001
"Talent, On Loan, From God" --Rush Limbaugh--
Member since Sept 10, 2001
"Talent, On Loan, From God" --Rush Limbaugh--
Thanks for your helpful replies...I found the problem after doing the blow test Cyclerob posted before, and found the hoses were connected properly and were not pinched. The problem was that a dirt-dauber (a non-stinging bee that builds nests in small holes) had plugged the end of the canister vent hose with dried mud, effectively sealing it. After cleaning it out, no more tank vacuum!
I wouldn't have thought to look for that until I went to blow in the hoses and saw it, so thanks again Cyclerob.
So if your tank sucks, something's wrong! I thought it was normal since it has done it since I bought the bike used in Mississippi, where dirt daubers abound...I should have guessed! I hope no damage has been done to the canister assembly, etc. but everything seems normal.
I am curious, ebincia, what sort of problems can occur as a result of tank vacuum build-up (other than an imploded tank
)?
So if your tank sucks, something's wrong! I thought it was normal since it has done it since I bought the bike used in Mississippi, where dirt daubers abound...I should have guessed! I hope no damage has been done to the canister assembly, etc. but everything seems normal.
I am curious, ebincia, what sort of problems can occur as a result of tank vacuum build-up (other than an imploded tank
Rich
ADIOS!
ADIOS!
Sunbeemer,Sunbeemer wrote: I am curious, ebincia, what sort of problems can occur as a result of tank vacuum build-up (other than an imploded tank)?
I am speaking from "K" bike experiense, so it may not apply to the oilheads. Problems caused by clogged cannisters: fuel pump failure, collapsed tank, sudden engine cutout while riding, intermittent run/stall problems. In extreme cases injector problems.
I was very happy to do (what the "K" bike guys call) a "cannisterectomy" at 65K after struggling with intermittent running for abour three months. Hopefully I did not cause any other damage. However I do not know if this applies to the "R" bikes. Sorry if I misled . Perhaps Cyclerob can chime in and clarify, as he is an authotity on the R11R.
Thanks ebincia. No you did not mislead, and I appreciate all the responses...it helps narrow down the cause of the problem when others share their experiences, but this case was just wierd! I've considered doin a "canisterectomy" too, but I like not smelling gasoline vapors in my garage! 
Rich
ADIOS!
ADIOS!
Thank you all for the replies.
I was riding my bike for 35k with the switched hoses. BMW technician, who worked on my bike, was correct and now the hoses routed properly. The problem now is in the charcoal canister. As I took it of the bike, the canister is completely clogged. Just a little fuel and wire hanger is not enough to bring it back to life. Both vents in the front of the canister are OK, but the one in the center is pretty much clogged, or the valve is fried. I am now left with two choices.
1. New canister for $75.00
2. Canisterectomy for FREE.

I was riding my bike for 35k with the switched hoses. BMW technician, who worked on my bike, was correct and now the hoses routed properly. The problem now is in the charcoal canister. As I took it of the bike, the canister is completely clogged. Just a little fuel and wire hanger is not enough to bring it back to life. Both vents in the front of the canister are OK, but the one in the center is pretty much clogged, or the valve is fried. I am now left with two choices.
1. New canister for $75.00
2. Canisterectomy for FREE.
